Skip to main content
Remindax
AI SmartDoc NEW Pricing

Login Signup Free
HR Glossary

Common Law Test: What It Means for Employers

The common-law test is the control-based test, taken from the law of agency, that the IRS, the EEOC, the NLRB and courts applying ERISA use to decide whether a worker is an employee: a worker is generally an employee when the business has the right to direct and control not only what work is done but how it is done.

  • Last reviewed November 2026
  • 11 min read
  • 21 primary sources
General information - not legal, tax or HR advice

Remindax does not provide legal, tax, or HR advisory services, and this page is for general informational purposes only - consult a qualified attorney, accountant, or HR professional for guidance specific to your situation.

Section 01

Quick facts

  • ✓Federal tax: anyone who is an employee "under the usual common law rules" is an employee for Social Security and Medicare tax (26 U.S.C. 3121(d)(2)).
  • ✓The right to control is enough. The employer does not have to actually direct how the work is done (26 CFR 31.3121(d)-1(c)(2)).
  • ✓Where a federal law defines "employee" only as "any individual employed by an employer," the Supreme Court presumes Congress meant the common-law agency test (Nationwide Mutual Ins. Co. v. Darden, 1992, applying it to ERISA).
  • ✓NLRB, as of its June 13, 2023 Atlanta Opera decision: common-law factors from the Restatement (Second) of Agency, with no single factor decisive.
  • ✓The FLSA does not use this test. It asks about economic dependence (29 CFR 795.105), and DOL's February 2026 proposal to change that rule had no final rule in the Federal Register as of November 17, 2026.
Section 02

What it means in practice

The common-law test is a legal standard, not one checklist: was the relationship one of master and servant, in the old agency-law phrase, or of a business hiring an independent contractor? Our independent contractor page covers the IRS's three evidence categories, Section 530 relief and the Voluntary Classification Settlement Program. This page covers where the test comes from and how the IRS, the courts, the EEOC and the NLRB each apply it. It does not decide any particular worker's status.

The core rule in the tax regulations. 26 CFR 31.3121(d)-1(c)(2) says an employment relationship generally exists when the business has the right to control and direct the worker "not only as to the result to be accomplished by the work but also as to the details and means by which that result is accomplished." It is not necessary that the employer actually direct or control the manner of the work; having the right is sufficient. The right to discharge is "an important factor," and furnishing tools and a place to work are characteristic of an employer but not present in every case. A worker controlled only as to the result is an independent contractor; physicians, lawyers, auctioneers and others offering their services to the public are the regulation's examples. Doubtful cases turn on the particular facts.

One of three tax tests. Section 3121(d) of the Internal Revenue Code defines "employee" for Social Security and Medicare tax (see FICA) in three ways: any officer of a corporation; any individual who has the status of an employee under the usual common-law rules; and workers in four listed occupations (see statutory employee). The regulation calls these "separate and independent tests"; meeting any one is enough. If the relationship exists, the parties' label is "immaterial," whether the worker is called a partner, agent or independent contractor, and managers and supervisors are employees too.

Same words for income tax withholding and FUTA. The withholding regulation (26 CFR 31.3401(c)-1) and the FUTA regulation (26 CFR 31.3306(i)-1) repeat the same control language and labels rule. An officer is generally an employee unless the officer performs no or only minor services and is not paid; a director acting only as a director is not. So a common-law employee for one federal employment tax is generally one for all three, while the statutory categories differ by tax.

From 20 factors to three categories. Revenue Ruling 87-41 published 20 factors drawn from court decisions. The IRS's 1996 classification training materials, which state they are not authority, say these factors are "an analytical tool and not the legal test"; the legal test is whether there is a right to direct and control the means and details of the work. They add that some factors "are no longer as relevant as they once were," that control is a matter of degree, and that one worker can have dual status, doing one service as a contractor and another as an employee for the same business. Publication 15-A (2026) now groups the evidence into behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship.

IRS example: own tools, still an employee. In Publication 15-A (2026), Milton Manning, a tile setter, works full time at a corporation's sites under an oral agreement, using his own tools. The company supplies materials, inspects often, pays by the piece and carries his workers' compensation; he has no separate business, and either side can end the arrangement at any time. The IRS concludes he is an employee.

IRS example: an hourly estimate that is not hourly pay. Vera Elm, an electrician, estimates a job at $16 an hour for 400 hours ($6,400). She is paid $1,280 every two weeks for 10 weeks, five payments totaling $6,400, whatever hours she works, and advertises for other jobs. The IRS says this is not payment by the hour and that she is an independent contractor: her pay is fixed by the job.

ERISA and other statutes: Darden. Robert Darden sold insurance only for Nationwide from 1962 to 1980 and was enrolled in its agents' retirement plan. Suing under ERISA for plan benefits required him to be an "employee," defined as "any individual employed by an employer" (29 U.S.C. 1002(6)). In a unanimous 1992 opinion the Supreme Court called that definition "completely circular," held that ERISA incorporates traditional agency-law criteria, and presumed that Congress means the common-law test whenever a statute does not helpfully define "employee." This matters for employee benefit plans, whose ERISA participants are employees and former employees.

The Reid factors. Darden adopted the list from Community for Creative Non-Violence v. Reid (1989). The main question is the hiring party's right to control the manner and means by which the product is accomplished. The other factors are: the skill required; the source of the instrumentalities and tools; the location of the work; the duration of the relationship; whether the hiring party has the right to assign additional projects; the hired party's discretion over when and how long to work; the method of payment; the hired party's role in hiring and paying assistants; whether the work is part of the hiring party's regular business; whether the hiring party is in business; the provision of employee benefits; and the tax treatment of the hired party. No one factor is determinative, and the test has "no shorthand formula or magic phrase."

How the Court applied it in Reid. A nonprofit commissioned a statue and directed enough of the work to make sure it met its specifications. The Court said control over the details of the product was not dispositive, and the other factors pointed the other way: a skilled occupation; the sculptor's own tools and Baltimore studio; under two months of work; no right to assign more projects; his own hours apart from the deadline; $15,000 paid for a specific job; his own assistants; and no payroll taxes or benefits. He was an independent contractor.

Not the FLSA. Darden contrasted the Fair Labor Standards Act, which defines "employ" to include "to suffer or permit to work," a definition the Court said covers some workers who might not qualify under traditional agency principles. The FLSA regulation (29 CFR 795.105, eCFR as of November 1, 2026) asks whether the worker is economically dependent on the business or in business for themself. DOL announced a proposal to change the rule on February 26, 2026 (91 FR 9932); comments closed April 28, 2026, and a Federal Register search on November 17, 2026 found no final rule.

Title VII, the ADA, the ADEA and the EPA. The EEOC Compliance Manual, Section 2 (May 12, 2000), section 2-III.A.1, asks whether the employer controls "the means and manner of the worker's work performance," looking at all aspects of the relationship. Its factors track the Reid list and add the right to discharge and whether both parties believe they are creating an employment relationship. Not all, or even most, need be present. In one EEOC example, a staffing firm places an accountant on a long-term client project under a contract calling her an independent contractor; the client supervises her, sets her schedule and supplies equipment. She is an employee of both businesses (see co-employment).

Owners and directors: Clackamas. In Clackamas Gastroenterology Associates v. Wells (2003), the question was whether four physician-shareholders who formed the board counted toward the ADA's 15-employee threshold. The Supreme Court called "the common-law element of control" the principal guidepost and endorsed six EEOC factors: whether the organization can hire or fire the person or set work rules; how much it supervises the work; whether the person reports to someone higher; how much the person can influence the organization; whether written agreements show the parties intended employment; and whether the person shares in profits, losses and liabilities. A title such as partner or director does not settle it. Federal employment tax differs: section 3121(d)(1) makes a corporate officer an employee by statute.

The NLRA and the NLRB. Darden recounts that after the Court read "employee" broadly under the National Labor Relations Act in 1944, Congress amended the Act, and general agency principles now separate employees from contractors under it. The NLRB has changed how it weighs the factors. In SuperShuttle DFW (January 25, 2019) it overruled its 2014 FedEx Home Delivery decision. In The Atlanta Opera (June 13, 2023, 372 NLRB No. 95) it overruled SuperShuttle and returned to the 2014 standard, applying the ten factors of Restatement (Second) of Agency section 220, such as control by agreement over the details of the work, a distinct occupation, skill, who supplies tools and the workplace, and pay by time or by the job. Entrepreneurial opportunity is weighed with the other factors, not as the "animating principle," by asking whether the worker is "rendering services as part of an independent business." The Board declined to adopt an ABC test or an economic-dependence test. The standard has moved with Board decisions, so check for later changes.

Where states differ: California (example). Federal common-law status does not decide state law. The California Employment Development Department says Assembly Bill 5, effective January 1, 2020, codified the ABC test for most of the Labor Code and the Unemployment Insurance Code. A worker is presumed to be an employee unless the hiring entity shows all three conditions: freedom from control, under contract and in fact; work outside the usual course of its business; and an independently established business of the same type. For listed exceptions the older Borello multifactor test applies, which asks about control over the manner and means of the work, control that "may be indirect and need not be actually exercised." Check your own state agency.

How a business works through the federal tax test. First, identify which law the question is under. Second, gather the facts on the right to control, from the contract and from actual practice. Third, check the statutory routes: a working corporate officer is an employee for tax, and a common-law contractor may still be a statutory employee. Fourth, the IRS says to document each factor used. Fifth, the firm or the worker can file Form SS-8 for an IRS determination, which the IRS says may take at least six months. A worker treated as a contractor is generally reported on Form 1099, often after providing a Form W-9, and owes self-employment tax rather than having FICA withheld.

FAQ: Can we get an SS-8 ruling before hiring someone? No. The Form SS-8 instructions (January 2024) say the IRS does not issue determinations for proposed transactions, hypothetical situations or cases in current worker classification litigation.

FAQ: Can one SS-8 cover a whole group of workers? Yes. A firm completes the form for one worker and attaches a list of all affected workers in that class. The determination binds the IRS only while its facts and law are unchanged.

FAQ: Can a worker be an employee under one law and not another? Yes. The NLRB's common-law test, the FLSA economic dependence rule and California's ABC presumption are separate standards; see employment status and, for staffing arrangements, contingent worker.

Section 03

Why it matters and common mistakes

Treating a hands-off practice as decisive. The tax regulations say the right to control is enough even if the employer never exercises it (26 CFR 31.3121(d)-1(c)(2)).

Relying on the contract label. The regulations call the parties' description of the relationship immaterial, the EEOC says a contract label does not control, and Clackamas says a document styled "employment agreement" does not decide status by itself.

Counting factors. Darden and Reid say no one factor is determinative, and the IRS says no set number of factors decides status.

Assuming the common-law answer settles the FLSA or state law. Darden says the FLSA's "suffer or permit" definition reaches some workers the common law would not, and California presumes employee status under its ABC test.

Assuming owners are never, or always, employees. A working corporate officer is generally an employee for federal employment tax; under the ADA, Clackamas makes shareholder-directors a control question.

Classifying without a reasonable basis. The IRS says a business that treats an employee as an independent contractor with no reasonable basis may be held liable for employment taxes for that worker, and the relief provisions do not apply.

Counting on Form SS-8 to stop the clock. The SS-8 instructions say filing it does not extend the time to file a refund claim.

Section 04

How Remindax helps

Remindax helps you track the dates and deadlines tied to periodic worker classification reviews and Form SS-8 requests and sends reminders before they're due.

  • ✓Reminders by Email, SMS and WhatsApp
  • ✓An owner and a due date on every item
  • ✓Forever-free plan, no credit card required
Start forever free
Section 06

Sources & References

Last reviewed: November 2026. Figures are reviewed annually - see Sources & References for current figures.

Keep every HR date on one calendar

Track the deadlines tied to periodic worker classification reviews and Form SS-8 requests - with automatic reminders before anything is due.

GDPR-ready | AWS secure cloud | Encrypted storage | Setup under 5 minutes