Skip to main content
Remindax
AI SmartDoc NEW Pricing

Login Signup Free
HR Glossary

Evidence of Insurability: What It Means for Employers

Evidence of insurability (EOI) is the health information, such as a medical questionnaire or a physical exam, that a group life or disability insurer reviews before it approves coverage that is not issued automatically, such as an amount above the plan's guaranteed level, an increase after the first enrollment window, or a late enrollment.

  • Last reviewed November 2026
  • 11 min read
  • 23 primary sources
General information - not legal, tax or HR advice

Remindax does not provide legal, tax, or HR advisory services, and this page is for general informational purposes only - consult a qualified attorney, accountant, or HR professional for guidance specific to your situation.

Section 01

Quick facts

  • ✓Federal employees (FEGLI): an employee may cancel a waiver of Basic, Option A or Option B by providing "satisfactory medical evidence of insurability" only after at least 1 year has passed since the waiver took effect; Option C cannot be added this way (5 CFR 870.503 and 870.506; FEGLI Handbook).
  • ✓The FEGLI form is the Request for Insurance (SF 2822); the physician sends it to OFEGLI, which must receive it within 60 days of the exam, and the employee pays any exam fee (FEGLI Handbook).
  • ✓Group health plans cannot use it: HIPAA rules list "evidence of insurability" as a health factor barred from eligibility rules, including late enrollment (29 CFR 2590.702).
  • ✓Disability income coverage and accident-only coverage are "excepted benefits" that the HIPAA group health rules do not reach (29 CFR 2590.732(c)(2)).
  • ✓Tax link (2026): the cost of employer group-term life coverage above $50,000 is taxable wages, figured with the IRS Table 2-2 monthly rates per $1,000 (Pub 15-B (2026)) [VERIFY ANNUALLY].
  • ✓Military (2026): veterans can get VGLI without a health review within 240 days of leaving service; from day 241 up to 1 year and 120 days, evidence of good health is required (VA; 38 CFR 9.2).
  • ✓DOL settlements (2023-2024): several group life insurers agreed not to deny death claims for missing EOI once premiums were collected for 90 days or three months (DOL news releases).
Section 02

What it means in practice

What the term means. Group life and disability plans often enroll eligible employees in a base amount without health questions. Coverage beyond that, or requested outside the policy's window, may be underwritten: the insurer reviews health information and decides whether to approve it. That health information is the evidence of insurability. Federal programs use the same idea: OPM's FEGLI rules speak of "satisfactory medical evidence of insurability" and the VA's rules of "proof of good health." The triggers, amounts and forms are set by each policy; this entry explains the federal framework around them.

Why it exists for life and disability but not health coverage. For group health plans, federal law takes this tool away. The HIPAA nondiscrimination rule at 29 CFR 2590.702 lists health factors that a group health plan and its insurer may not use in eligibility rules, and "evidence of insurability" is one of them, alongside health status, medical history, claims experience, genetic information and disability. Eligibility rules expressly include late and special enrollment. The regulation's examples say a plan violates the rule if employees who miss a 30-day window can enroll later only by passing a physical, or if late enrollees must "provide evidence of good health"; a plan may instead limit late enrollees to one option, because enrollment timing is not a health factor. Under the Affordable Care Act, 45 CFR 147.104 requires health insurers to accept any employer or individual that applies for their products, though they may restrict enrollment to open or special enrollment periods, and 45 CFR 147.108 bars preexisting condition exclusions. These rules govern medical coverage, which is why questions such as which of two health plans pays first, covered under secondary insurance, never involve EOI.

Where life and disability coverage fit. A "group health plan" under 29 CFR 2590.732 is a welfare plan to the extent it provides medical care. Life insurance pays a death benefit, not medical care, and the same section lists disability income coverage and accident-only coverage (including accidental death and dismemberment) as benefits "excepted in all circumstances" from these rules. So an insurer may still ask health questions before issuing life or disability income coverage, subject to the policy, state law and the rules below. (Job protection during a disability absence is a separate topic; see disability leave.) Many employers offer these products as voluntary benefits; the April 2023 DOL settlement described below involved supplemental life coverage.

A federal model: how FEGLI handles it. OPM's FEGLI program shows the full process in public documents. Eligible employees are enrolled in Basic insurance automatically, and new employees elect optional coverage on the Life Insurance Election (SF 2817). Someone who waived coverage can later get it in three ways: during an open season, within 60 days after a FEGLI life event (marriage, divorce, death of a spouse or acquiring an eligible child), or by proving insurability. The medical route works like this:

1. At least one year must have passed since the effective date of the waiver (5 CFR 870.503 and 870.506). 2. The employing agency completes Part A of the Request for Insurance (SF 2822), and the employee completes and signs Part C. 3. A physician or other provider examines the employee, completes Part B and sends the form to the Office of Federal Employees' Group Life Insurance (OFEGLI), which must receive it within 60 days of the exam. The employee pays any exam fee. 4. OFEGLI returns the approved or denied form to the employing office, which files it in the Official Personnel Folder. 5. For Option A or Option B, the employee files an SF 2817 within 60 days after the approval date, and the coverage starts when the office has the election and the employee is in pay and duty status. If the employee is not in pay and duty status within 60 days after approval, the approval is revoked and the process starts over.

Three FEGLI details stand out. First, Option C (family coverage) cannot be elected or increased with medical information. Second, OFEGLI's decision on medical evidence cannot be appealed to OPM or the Merit Systems Protection Board, and the handbook says there is no reconsideration right for it. Third, when group coverage ends for any reason other than voluntary cancellation, an employee may convert to an individual policy with "no medical examination" required (5 CFR 870.603). The handbook on OPM's site is the June 2019 edition.

Military coverage: proof of good health windows. The VA's programs use time windows rather than dollar thresholds. Service members eligible for full-time Servicemembers' Group Life Insurance (SGLI) are enrolled automatically, with coverage up to $500,000 in $50,000 increments, according to the VA. On leaving service, a veteran can apply for Veterans' Group Life Insurance (VGLI) up to the SGLI amount; the VA says no health review is needed within 240 days, and 38 CFR 9.2(c) requires evidence of insurability after that, up to 1 year and 120 days after separation. Under 38 CFR 9.24, a member married to another member can elect spousal coverage within 240 days of the marriage without proof of the spouse's good health, and after that only by submitting that proof. The VA also says SGLI (within 120 days of discharge) and VGLI can be converted to an individual policy without proof of good health.

How EOI interacts with the tax rules. IRS Publication 15-B (2026) sets the conditions for the group-term life exclusion. One is that the amount for each employee comes from a formula "that prevents individual selection," based on factors such as age, service, pay or position. Group-term life generally must cover at least 10 full-time employees, but an employer with fewer can still qualify if, among other conditions, any evidence of insurability is "limited to a medical questionnaire (completed by the employee) that doesn't require a physical" (26 CFR 1.79-1(c)(2)). The cost of up to $50,000 of coverage is excluded from wages; the cost above that, less what the employee paid, is imputed income reported in boxes 1, 3 and 5 of Form W-2 and in box 12 with code C. EOI approval sets when a higher amount, and its imputed income, starts.

Employee-paid supplemental life can count too. Pub 15-B says an employer "carries" a policy even if it pays none of the cost when it arranges for employees to pay and charges at least one employee less than, and at least one more than, the Table 2-2 cost of their insurance. When that test is met, the supplemental amount is added to the employer-paid amount when measuring coverage above $50,000.

Example 1: a mid-year approval (illustration). An employer provides $50,000 of group-term life. On July 1, an employee who will be 47 at year end is approved through EOI for $100,000 of supplemental coverage under the same employer-carried policy, paying $8 a month after tax. The 2026 Table 2-2 rate for ages 45 through 49 is $0.15 per $1,000 per month. Coverage above $50,000 is $100,000, so the cost for July through December is 100 x $0.15 x 6 = $90. The employee paid $48, so $42 is added to 2026 wages. If the approval had been effective January 1 with the same monthly payment, the result would be 100 x $0.15 x 12 = $180, less $96, or $84.

Example 2: the straddle test (illustration). A supplemental life plan charges every employee a flat $0.12 per $1,000 per month. A 30-year-old's 2026 Table 2-2 cost is $0.08, so that employee pays more than the table cost; a 60-year-old's cost is $0.66, so that employee pays less. Because at least one employee pays more and one pays less, the employer is treated as carrying the policy, and the supplemental coverage counts toward the $50,000 measurement.

Example 3: a FEGLI timeline (illustration). A federal employee waived Option B on joining an agency. Two years later, with no life event, the employee can use the SF 2822 because more than one year has passed since the waiver. If the exam is on March 3, OFEGLI must receive the form by May 2. If OFEGLI approves on May 20, the employee has until July 19 to file the SF 2817 electing Option B multiples.

The ERISA risk: collecting premiums without approval. The Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) has investigated group life insurers over EOI. In April 2023, the DOL announced a settlement after EBSA found an insurer had collected supplemental life premiums and then denied claims after participants died because evidence of insurability was missing; the settlement bars denials for that reason "when premiums were collected for more than three months." That release also states that group policyholders, "such as employers sponsoring plans, who collect premiums may be liable" for beneficiaries' supplemental claims if they failed to tell participants that the insurer had not approved their EOI. Settlements announced in September 2023 and June 2024 with other insurers set a 90-day or three-month limit, and one also limits requests for EOI from existing participants to their first year of premiums. The settlements bind the named insurers, not every plan, but the employer often runs the payroll deduction, which makes this part of employee benefits administration.

Plan documents and records. ERISA's summary plan description rule, 29 CFR 2520.102-3, requires the SPD to describe the plan's eligibility provisions and to clearly identify circumstances that may result in "disqualification, ineligibility, or denial" of benefits a participant might otherwise expect. A requirement to provide EOI above a stated amount is that kind of condition. With FEGLI's SF 2822, the physician sends health answers to OFEGLI and only the decision returns to the agency. Where an employer does hold health information, federal rules can require it to be kept apart from personnel files; for example, EEOC regulations at 29 CFR 1635.9 require genetic information an employer holds in writing about an employee to be kept in medical files separate from personnel files.

Where states differ. Group life insurance policies are regulated under state insurance law, and the IRS regulation notes that state limits on group-term amounts can apply (26 CFR 1.79-1(e)). As examples, Florida Statutes section 627.566 (2025) and Maine Revised Statutes Title 24-A, section 2621 require a group life policy to let a person whose coverage ends because employment or eligibility ends obtain an individual policy "without evidence of insurability" if the application and first premium reach the insurer within 31 days. Other states word this differently.

Question: Does a qualifying life event remove EOI? Only if the plan says so. FEGLI life events allow elections up to five multiples of Options B and C within 60 days without medical evidence. A health plan qualifying life event is a separate rule.

Question: Can a small employer require a physical exam? The policy can, but a group of fewer than 10 full-time employees relying on the 26 CFR 1.79-1(c)(2) exception must limit EOI affecting eligibility or amount to a questionnaire without a physical.

This entry summarizes federal rules and two state examples; it does not decide whether a person is insurable or a plan complies.

Section 03

Why it matters and common mistakes

Deducting premiums for an amount that still needs EOI. EBSA found insurers collected premiums for years and then denied death claims for missing EOI, and the 2023 settlement release says employers that collect premiums may be liable if they did not tell participants EOI was not approved.

Adding EOI to a group health plan. 29 CFR 2590.702 bars requiring a physical or evidence of good health for late enrollment.

Starting coverage and payroll before approval. In FEGLI, Optional coverage takes effect no earlier than the approval date, once the election is filed and the employee is in pay and duty status, so deductions keyed to the application date can run ahead of coverage.

Forgetting imputed income on approved increases. Coverage above $50,000 under an employer-carried policy is valued with Table 2-2 from the month coverage starts, less employee payments (Pub 15-B (2026)).

Letting approvals lapse. FEGLI Options A and B require an SF 2817 within 60 days of approval, and an approval is revoked if the employee is not in pay and duty status within 60 days.

Leaving EOI out of the SPD. 29 CFR 2520.102-3 requires the SPD to describe eligibility and circumstances that can lead to denial of benefits.

Section 04

How Remindax helps

Remindax helps you track the dates and deadlines tied to evidence of insurability requests, insurer approval dates and election windows and sends reminders before they're due.

  • ✓Reminders by Email, SMS and WhatsApp
  • ✓An owner and a due date on every item
  • ✓Forever-free plan, no credit card required
Start forever free
Section 06

Sources & References

Last reviewed: November 2026. Figures are reviewed annually - see Sources & References for current figures.

Keep every HR date on one calendar

Track the deadlines tied to evidence of insurability requests, insurer approval dates and election windows - with automatic reminders before anything is due.

GDPR-ready | AWS secure cloud | Encrypted storage | Setup under 5 minutes