Remindax does not provide legal, tax, or HR advisory services, and this page is for general informational purposes only - consult a qualified attorney, accountant, or HR professional for guidance specific to your situation.
Quick facts
- ✓Federal source until 2026: 41 CFR 60-2.10 to 60-2.17 (known as Revised Order 4) required federal supply and service contractors with 50 or more employees and a contract of at least $50,000 to run six quantitative analyses, ending in placement goals.
- ✓January 21, 2025: Executive Order 14173 revoked Executive Order 11246, the authority for those rules, and told OFCCP to stop allowing or encouraging contractor workforce balancing based on race, color, sex, sexual preference, religion or national origin.
- ✓October 26, 2026: a DOL final rule (91 FR 54444) rescinded 41 CFR parts 60-1, 60-2, 60-4 and related parts. The eCFR shows part 60-2 removed as of that date.
- ✓September 21, 2026: a separate DOL final rule (91 FR 54482) removed the Section 503 7 percent utilization goal and utilization analysis at 41 CFR 60-741.45; the eCFR now lists that section as [Reserved].
- ✓Still in force (eCFR, November 2026): the Section 503 and VEVRAA written affirmative action programs, and the VEVRAA hiring benchmark, which is not a utilization analysis.
- ✓Some states still require one for state contractors, for example Minnesota Rules 5000.3450.
What it means in practice
What the term means. A utilization analysis asks one question for each job group: is the share of a given group in the job group lower than the group's share of the people qualified and available for that work? The federal rules called a "yes" answer underutilization. The analysis was the core of the diagnostic half of an affirmative action program; the other half was action-oriented programs to address what the analysis found. A utilization analysis is narrower than a general workforce analysis, and it is different from an adverse impact review, which compares selection rates in a hiring or promotion decision rather than the makeup of the workforce at a point in time.
Where the federal requirement came from. Executive Order 11246, issued in 1965, required federal contracts to include an equal opportunity clause with an affirmative action duty. DOL first codified the nonconstruction rules in 41 CFR part 60-2 in 1970 and revised them in 2000. Under 41 CFR 60-2.1(b), as DOL summarized it in the 2026 rescission rule, nonconstruction contractors with 50 or more employees and a contract of at least $50,000 had to develop and maintain a written program for each establishment. Construction contractors were covered by part 60-4, which used government-set participation goals, such as 6.9 percent of hours worked in each trade for women, instead of a contractor-run utilization analysis.
The six required analyses. Section 60-2.10(b), as it read before October 26, 2026, listed six quantitative analyses: (1) an organizational profile (60-2.11); (2) a job group analysis (60-2.12); (3) placement of incumbents in job groups (60-2.13); (4) determining availability (60-2.14); (5) comparing incumbency to availability (60-2.15); and (6) placement goals (60-2.16). Section 60-2.17 added four more elements: a responsible official, identification of problem areas, action-oriented programs and periodic internal audits. Contractors had to keep documentation of all of it and make it available to OFCCP (60-2.10(c)).
Step 1: organizational profile. The contractor chose either an organizational display or a workforce analysis. The display was a chart, table or similar presentation of each organizational unit, showing the unit supervisor's job title, gender, race and ethnicity, and the number of male and female incumbents, broken out for Blacks, Hispanics, Asians/Pacific Islanders and American Indians/Alaskan Natives. The workforce analysis option listed every job title, ranked from lowest to highest paid within each department, with the same counts and pay rates. The display works much like an org chart with headcounts.
Step 2: job group analysis. Job titles at the establishment with similar content, wage rates and opportunities were combined into job groups, and the analysis had to list the titles in each group (60-2.12(b) and (c)). A contractor with fewer than 150 employees in total could use the nine EEO-1 categories as its job groups: officials and managers, professionals, technicians, sales, office and clerical, craft workers, operatives, laborers and service workers (60-2.12(e)).
Step 3: incumbency. For each job group, the contractor stated its percentages of minorities and of women (60-2.13).
Step 4: availability. Availability was an estimate of qualified minorities or women available for a job group, expressed as a percentage of all qualified people available for it (60-2.14(a)). The contractor had to consider at least two factors: the percentage with the requisite skills in the reasonable recruitment area, and the percentage among employees who were promotable, transferable or trainable within the organization. It had to use the most current and discrete statistics available, such as census data, local job service data or data from colleges and training institutions, and could not draw the recruitment area or the internal pool in a way that excluded minorities or women. Where a job group mixed titles with different availability, the contractor weighted each title's availability by its share of the group's incumbents and added the results to get a composite figure (60-2.14(g)).
Steps 5 and 6: comparison and placement goals. The contractor compared incumbency with availability for each job group. When the percentage of minorities or women was "less than would reasonably be expected given their availability," it had to set an annual percentage placement goal at least equal to the availability figure (60-2.15(b), 60-2.16(c)). The rule did not set a single numeric test for "less than would reasonably be expected." It contemplated one goal for all minorities, with separate goals possible where a particular group showed a substantial disparity (60-2.16(d)). The regulation said goals were not quotas, ceilings, floors or set-asides, did not justify a preference for any individual, and did not require hiring a less qualified person; it also said a required goal was not a finding or admission of discrimination (60-2.16(b) and (e)).
Illustration 1: a composite availability figure. This shows the former 60-2.14(g) arithmetic. A job group has two titles. Title A holds 60 percent of the group's incumbents and has 40 percent availability for women; Title B holds 40 percent and has 25 percent availability. Composite availability is (0.60 x 40) + (0.40 x 25) = 24 + 10 = 34 percent. If women held 28 percent of the jobs and the contractor judged that shortfall to be less than reasonably expected, the old rule would have required an annual placement goal of at least 34 percent for women in that job group.
Why the federal requirement ended. Executive Order 14173 revoked Executive Order 11246, let contractors keep following the prior rules for 90 days, and directed OFCCP to immediately stop holding contractors responsible for "affirmative action" and to stop allowing or encouraging workforce balancing. OFCCP says contractors had to wind down Executive Order 11246 compliance by April 21, 2025. The final rule published August 21, 2026 then rescinded the implementing regulations effective October 26, 2026. DOL relied on the revocation and on its view that the placement goal framework is legally vulnerable, noting that since fiscal year 2020 OFCCP had issued over 40 notices of violation for failing to conduct the utilization analysis or to execute action-oriented programs.
The Section 503 disability utilization analysis. A second federal utilization analysis existed under Section 503 of the Rehabilitation Act. From DOL's 2013 rule until September 2026, 41 CFR 60-741.45 set a 7 percent utilization goal for qualified individuals with disabilities in each job group and required contractors to evaluate utilization against it every year, using the same job groups as their Executive Order 11246 analysis. A contractor with 100 or fewer employees could measure its whole workforce instead. A shortfall triggered a review of personnel processes and outreach, plus action-oriented programs. DOL's final rule effective September 21, 2026 removed the goal and the analysis, along with the disability self-identification invitation (60-741.42) and related data collection (60-741.44(k)). DOL said the analysis was unworkable without Executive Order 11246 job groups, that the goal depended on disability inquiries it views as inconsistent with the ADA, and that the statute does not require it. The rule adds that contractors "remain free to conduct utilization analyses" at their own discretion, consistent with the ADA and other law.
What federal contractors still do. The Section 503 written program still applies to contractors with 50 or more employees and a contract of $50,000 or more; it is prepared within 120 days of a contract and updated each year (60-741.40). It includes an annual assessment of outreach and an audit and reporting system, and new paragraph 60-741.44(l) says contractors need not consider quantitative data on referrals, applicants or hires with disabilities when judging effectiveness. Under VEVRAA, contractors with written programs still collect applicant and hire data on protected veterans each year (60-300.44(k)) and set an annual hiring benchmark (60-300.45). The benchmark is a single hiring yardstick, not a job-group comparison, and the regulation says "quotas are expressly forbidden." DOL's VEVRAA rule, also effective September 21, 2026, did not change the benchmark. OFCCP states that Section 503 and VEVRAA "remain in effect."
Interacting federal rules. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, enforced by the EEOC, says in section 703(j) that it does not require preferential treatment because of an imbalance between an employer's workforce and the available work force. The EEOC says a DEI initiative may be unlawful if an employment action is motivated in whole or in part by race, sex or another protected characteristic. On July 6, 2026 the EEOC rescinded its 1979 affirmative action guidelines (29 CFR part 1608). The Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures remain at 29 CFR part 1607 as of November 2026. Section 1607.4(D) says agencies may infer adverse impact when an employer has not kept required selection data and has an underutilization of a group compared with the relevant labor market.
Where states differ. State contract laws can still require a utilization analysis. Two examples follow; other states differ, so check the state contracting or civil rights agency. Minnesota: under Minnesota Statutes section 363A.36, a state agency may not sign a contract over $100,000 with a business that had 40 or more full-time employees in Minnesota, or in its home state, on a single day in the prior 12 months unless the business holds a workforce certificate, which lasts four years and carries a $250 fee. The certificate rests on an affirmative action plan. Minnesota Rules 5000.3450 requires the plan to include a workforce analysis based on data no more than one year old, and an analysis of all major job groups that explains any underutilization, done separately for minorities and women, weighing at least eight listed factors for each. Part 5000.3460 requires goals and timetables where deficiencies exist, or a written factor analysis explaining why no goal was set. Part 5000.3420 requires the plan before a bid and an annual update. The statute allows fines of up to $5,000 per calendar year for each contract.
New Jersey takes a different route. Under the rules posted by the state's Division of Purchase and Property (N.J.A.C. 17:27, as adopted August 4, 2017), the state itself sets targeted county employment goals for goods and services vendors, comparing each vendor's occupational mix with county availability data for minorities and women (17:27-5.2). A vendor complies by meeting those percentages or by acting in good faith toward them (17:27-5.4). Vendors also show a federally approved program, a certificate of employee information report or a Form AA302 (17:27-4.3).
Illustration 2: a Minnesota bidder. This applies the statute and rules above to assumed facts. A business with 45 full-time employees in Minnesota plans to bid on a $150,000 state services contract. Because $150,000 is over $100,000 and 45 is at least 40, it needs a workforce certificate or a written exemption determination. Its plan would need a current workforce analysis, separate utilization analyses for minorities and women, and goals and timetables or a written factor analysis.
Recordkeeping. Minnesota requires support data, including progression line charts, seniority rosters, applicant flow data and applicant rejection ratios by minority and sex status, to be kept with the plan and produced on request (Minn. R. 5000.3460, subps. 10 and 11). Federal retention rules for the remaining programs are in 60-741.80 and 60-300.80.
FAQ: Is the VEVRAA hiring benchmark a utilization goal? No. It is a single annual benchmark for hiring protected veterans, set from the national figure OFCCP publishes or from five listed factors (60-300.45).
FAQ: Is underutilization proof of discrimination? The former federal rules said a placement goal was neither a finding nor an admission of discrimination, and former 60-741.45(g) said the same about missing the 7 percent goal. But under 29 CFR 1607.4(D), underutilization plus missing selection data can support an inference of adverse impact.
Why it matters and common mistakes
Treating old federal templates as current. Placement goals under 41 CFR 60-2 and the Section 503 7 percent analysis no longer exist in the eCFR, and the EEOC says employment actions motivated by race or sex may violate Title VII.
Using a goal as a hiring rule. Even when goals were required, 60-2.16(e) forbade quotas and preferences, and Minnesota Rules 5000.3460 says goals must not be rigid quotas.
Dropping a state requirement. A Minnesota workforce certificate still depends on an affirmative action plan with a utilization analysis. A certificate can be suspended or revoked, fines can reach $5,000 per year for each contract, and a contract can be terminated or voided.
Confusing utilization with adverse impact. A utilization analysis compares incumbents with availability. Adverse impact compares selection rates, and 29 CFR 1607.4(D) lets agencies infer adverse impact when selection data are missing and underutilization exists.
Deleting VEVRAA data along with the rescinded analyses. The 60-300.44(k) applicant and hire data and the 60-300.45 benchmark records must still be kept for three years.
How Remindax helps
Remindax helps you track the dates and deadlines tied to annual affirmative action plan updates, state workforce certificate renewals and related contractor compliance dates and sends reminders before they're due.
- ✓Reminders by Email, SMS and WhatsApp
- ✓An owner and a due date on every item
- ✓Forever-free plan, no credit card required
Sources & References
- *eCFR - 41 CFR part 60-2 as in effect October 1, 2026 (sections 60-2.10 to 60-2.17) - six quantitative analyses, organizational profile, job groups, EEO-1 categories under 150 employees, availability factors and composite weighting, comparison, placement goals and their limits, 60-2.17 elements
- *eCFR - 41 CFR part 60-2 version history (removed October 26, 2026) - part 60-2 sections shown as removed effective 2026-10-26
- *Federal Register (govinfo) - DOL, Rescission of Executive Order 11246 Implementing Regulations (91 FR 54444, Aug. 21, 2026) - effective October 26, 2026; history of part 60-2; 50 employees and $50,000; part 60-4 participation goals; 40-plus notices of violation since FY2020
- *Federal Register (govinfo) - Executive Order 14173 (90 FR 8633, Jan. 31, 2025) - revocation of EO 11246, 90-day period, OFCCP to cease affirmative action and workforce balancing
- *U.S. Department of Labor - Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs - wind-down by April 21, 2025; Section 503 and VEVRAA remain in effect
- *Federal Register (govinfo) - DOL, Modifications to the Section 503 Regulations (91 FR 54482, Aug. 21, 2026) - effective September 21, 2026; removal of 60-741.42, 60-741.44(k) and 60-741.45; 2013 origin of 7 percent goal; reasons; contractors remain free to conduct utilization analyses
- *eCFR - 41 CFR 60-741.45 as in effect September 1, 2026 (Section 503 utilization goals) - former 7 percent goal, job group method, 100-employee option, annual evaluation, problem areas, not a finding of discrimination
- *eCFR - 41 CFR 60-741.40 Section 503 affirmative action program applicability - 50 employees and $50,000; 120 days; annual update
- *eCFR - 41 CFR 60-741.44 Required contents of Section 503 programs - outreach assessment, audit and reporting system, (k) reserved, new (l)
- *eCFR - 41 CFR 60-300.44 Required contents of VEVRAA programs - annual applicant and hire data, three-year retention
- *eCFR - 41 CFR 60-300.45 VEVRAA benchmarks for hiring - annual benchmark, two methods, quotas forbidden, three-year records
- *Federal Register (govinfo) - DOL, Modifications to the VEVRAA Regulations (91 FR 54234, Aug. 21, 2026) - effective September 21, 2026; benchmark comments out of scope, benchmark unchanged
- *Federal Register (govinfo) - EEOC, Rescission of Guidelines on Affirmative Action (July 6, 2026) - 29 CFR part 1608 rescinded effective July 6, 2026; part 60-2 known as Revised Order 4; self-analysis reference
- *eCFR - 29 CFR 1607.4 Uniform Guidelines, information on impact - four-fifths rule; inference of adverse impact where data are missing and underutilization exists
- *EEOC - Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 - section 703(j) no preferential treatment for imbalance
- *EEOC - What You Should Know About DEI-Related Discrimination at Work - actions motivated in whole or in part by race or sex may be unlawful
- *Minnesota Statutes section 363A.36 Certificates of compliance for public contracts - $100,000 and 40 employees, four-year certificate, $250 fee, fines up to $5,000, suspension, contract termination or voiding
- *Minnesota Rules part 5000.3450 Workforce analysis; availability and utilization - workforce analysis data no more than one year old; utilization analysis separately for minorities and women; eight factors each
- *Minnesota Rules part 5000.3460 Goals and objectives; completion timetables - goals and timetables, not quotas, factor analysis where no goal, support data and copies
- *Minnesota Rules part 5000.3420 Affirmative action plans; contractors - plan before bid, at each establishment, annual review
- *New Jersey Division of Purchase and Property - N.J.A.C. 17:27 (as adopted August 4, 2017) - state-set targeted county goals (17:27-5.2), compliance by meeting goals or good faith (17:27-5.4), vendor evidence options (17:27-4.3)
Last reviewed: November 2026. Figures are reviewed annually - see Sources & References for current figures.
Keep every HR date on one calendar
Track the deadlines tied to annual affirmative action plan updates, state workforce certificate renewals and related contractor compliance dates - with automatic reminders before anything is due.
GDPR-ready | AWS secure cloud | Encrypted storage | Setup under 5 minutes