Remindax does not provide legal, tax, or HR advisory services, and this page is for general informational purposes only - consult a qualified attorney, accountant, or HR professional for guidance specific to your situation.
Quick facts
- ✓OPM's guide "Structured Interviews: A Practical Guide" (September 2008) says the behavioral interview gathers information about candidates' actual behavior during past experiences; situational questions instead ask what a candidate would do in a hypothetical scenario.
- ✓OPM recommends a common rating scale for all candidates with at least three proficiency levels, aiming for five to seven.
- ✓The Uniform Guidelines treat interviews, including "informal or casual interviews," as selection procedures, and a selection rate below four-fifths (80 percent) of the highest group's rate is generally regarded as evidence of adverse impact (29 CFR 1607.16, 1607.4).
- ✓Before a conditional job offer, the ADA bars questions about whether an applicant has a disability or its nature or severity, but allows questions about the ability to perform job-related functions (29 CFR 1630.13, 1630.14).
- ✓GINA bars employers from requesting genetic information, which includes family medical history (29 CFR 1635.8).
- ✓Title VII, the ADA and GINA cover private employers with 15 or more employees; the ADEA covers 20 or more (EEOC).
- ✓Interview records: at least one year under EEOC and ADEA rules (29 CFR 1602.14, 1627.3); federal contractors' disability and veterans rules name "interview notes" and generally require two years for larger contractors (41 CFR 60-741.80, 60-300.80, eCFR text checked November 2026).
What it means in practice
A behavioral-based interview question asks for a real example: "Describe a situation in which you dealt with individuals who were difficult, hostile, or distressed. Who was involved? What specific actions did you take and what was the result?" That sample comes from OPM's structured interview guide, which calls this format a behavioral description interview, also known as a behavioral event interview. OPM states the underlying premise as "the best predictor of future behavior on the job is past behavior under similar circumstances." Each question is tied to a competency the job requires, so the questions start from a job description and the behavioral competencies identified for the role.
Behavioral vs. situational questions. OPM contrasts the two formats. Behavioral questions look back at what the candidate did. Situational questions are "based on future-oriented behavior": they give a realistic job scenario, such as an angry client at the front desk who says an overdue check never arrived, and ask how the candidate would respond. OPM says the formats measure different aspects of performance and may be combined. OPM's Assessment Decision Guide adds that both formats rely on job-related critical incidents (examples of notably good or notably bad performance), both have proven effective, and behavioral description interviews have shown higher validity where the work is highly complex, such as professional and managerial jobs.
Why structure matters. OPM describes a structured interview as one in which all candidates are asked the same questions in the same order, all are evaluated on a common rating scale, and interviewers agree on acceptable answers. It says unstructured interviews show low reliability and low to moderate validity and are susceptible to legal challenges, and that interviews used to make employment decisions are subject to the same legal and psychometric requirements as any written test. The Assessment Decision Guide says interviews with higher degrees of structure show higher validity, rater reliability and rater agreement, and less adverse impact. Its validity table, adapted from Schmidt and Hunter (1998), lists an estimated validity of .51 for structured interviews and .38 for unstructured interviews.
How to build behavioral questions (OPM's steps). OPM's guide lays out eight steps. (1) Conduct a job analysis to identify the job's requirements and the competencies needed on entry. (2) Choose the competencies the interview will assess; OPM says interviews typically cover four to six. (3) Write questions with about six or seven subject matter experts, usually high-performing employees or supervisors at journey level or higher. Each question should measure at least one competency, draw out the situation, the actions the person took or did not take and their impact, and use superlatives such as "most," "last" or "worst" to focus the candidate on a specific incident. (4) Build a rating scale with example behaviors for each level. (5) Set the probes interviewers may use. (6) Pilot test the questions. (7) Create an interviewer's guide with competency definitions, questions, rating scales and probes. (8) Document the development process, including the job analysis.
Rating scales and probes. OPM says to use one proficiency range for all competencies (for example, 1 to 5), create at least three levels but aim for five to seven, and label at least three. For behavioral questions, subject matter experts write example behaviors for each level so interviewers have concrete anchors. A probe is a follow-up question that clarifies an answer. OPM says interviewers should use very similar probes for every candidate, decide the allowed range of probing in advance, and organize probes around the situation ("What factors led up to the situation?"), the action ("What is the first thing you did?") and the outcome ("What was the outcome?").
Running and scoring the interview. OPM's guide says to give every candidate the same amount of time, make the room accessible to candidates with disabilities, and not look at a resume or other supplemental documents during the interview. Notes should record actual answers and be detailed enough to document the reasoning for each rating. Appendix D recommends a panel of two or three interviewers, using the same interviewers across all candidates when feasible; each panelist rates independently, then the panel discusses discrepancies and records a consensus rating. Appendix F lists rating errors to train against, such as halo effect, leniency and "similar to me," and mistakes such as relying on first impressions.
Interviews are selection procedures under federal law. The Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures (29 CFR Part 1607) apply to tests and other selection procedures used as a basis for any employment decision, including hiring and promotion (29 CFR 1607.2). The definition of selection procedure runs "through informal or casual interviews and unscored application forms" (29 CFR 1607.16). A procedure with adverse impact on a race, sex or ethnic group is considered discriminatory unless validated or otherwise justified (29 CFR 1607.3). The guidelines say a content validity strategy is not appropriate for procedures that claim to measure traits or constructs such as judgment or leadership (29 CFR 1607.14). Title VII makes a practice with a disparate impact unlawful if the employer fails to show it is "job related for the position in question and consistent with business necessity" (42 U.S.C. 2000e-2(k)). The guidelines do not apply to ADEA or Rehabilitation Act obligations (29 CFR 1607.2(D)). See adverse impact; intentional differences in how candidates are questioned are disparate treatment.
Example 1: checking the interview stage (illustration). This arithmetic is our own illustration of the 29 CFR 1607.4(D) comparison, not a legal conclusion. A company interviews 50 men and advances 20 (40 percent), and interviews 40 women and advances 10 (25 percent). Twenty-five divided by 40 is 62.5 percent, below four-fifths, so the guideline would generally treat the gap as evidence of adverse impact. Under the "bottom line" rule, if the total selection process for the job does not show adverse impact, federal agencies usually will not expect each component to be evaluated, with stated exceptions (29 CFR 1607.4(C)). Differences based on small numbers that are not statistically significant may not constitute adverse impact.
Disability-related questions. Before a conditional offer, an employer may not ask whether an applicant has a disability or about its nature or severity (29 CFR 1630.13(a)). It may ask about the applicant's ability to perform job-related functions and may ask the applicant to describe or demonstrate how, with or without reasonable accommodation, they will perform them (29 CFR 1630.14(a)). The EEOC's 1995 enforcement guidance defines a disability-related question as one "likely to elicit information about a disability." It says an employer may state its attendance requirements and ask whether the applicant can meet them, and may ask how many days the applicant was absent from a prior job, but may not ask how many days the applicant was sick, or about job-related injuries or workers' compensation history. Generally an employer may not ask whether the applicant will need reasonable accommodation, except in limited cases such as an obvious or voluntarily disclosed disability. The EEOC adds that an applicant who needs an accommodation to apply, such as a sign language interpreter, must get one unless it causes significant difficulty or expense. See the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).
Example 2: rewriting a risky behavioral question (illustration). "Tell me about a time a health problem affected your work" invites the candidate to describe an impairment, which the EEOC guidance treats as likely to elicit disability information pre-offer, and it may also draw out family medical history covered by GINA. A version built on the EEOC's examples states the job's attendance requirement and asks whether the candidate can meet it, then uses a behavioral question about a competency, such as "Tell me about the last time you had to finish work by a deadline that was at risk. What did you do and what was the result?"
Genetic information, family and other protected traits. Behavioral questions invite personal stories, so the follow-ups matter. GINA says "request" includes asking about current health status in a way likely to result in obtaining genetic information; inadvertent acquisition, such as a candidate volunteering a parent's illness during casual conversation, falls under an exception (29 CFR 1635.8). The EEOC says pre-employment questions about pregnancy, marital status, number and ages of children, child care arrangements and a spouse's employment may be regarded as evidence of intent to discriminate, and asking such questions only of women (or only of men) is clearly discriminatory. It says employers other than religious organizations should avoid questions about religious affiliation, such as place or days of worship. Age questions are not unlawful in themselves under the ADEA but are "closely scrutinized" (29 CFR 1625.4, 1625.5). See the Age Discrimination in Employment Act.
Where states differ. As one labeled example, the California Labor Commissioner's Equal Pay Act FAQ says an employer generally cannot seek an applicant's salary history, orally or in writing, or rely on it in deciding whether to hire or what to pay (Lab. Code 432.3), though it may ask about salary expectations, and an applicant may volunteer salary history without prompting. As a second example, Washington law bars an employer from seeking an applicant's wage or salary history, but allows confirming it if the applicant volunteers it or after an offer with compensation is made (RCW 49.58.100). So "Tell me about a time you negotiated your pay at your last job" can raise state-law issues. Other states and cities have their own rules.
Keeping interview records. EEOC rules require keeping records having to do with hiring, including application forms, for one year from the making of the record or the personnel action, whichever is later, and all relevant records until final disposition once a charge is filed (29 CFR 1602.14). ADEA rules require keeping job applications and records of a refusal to hire for 1 year (29 CFR 1627.3). The Uniform Guidelines say users should keep information showing the impact of selection procedures by race, sex and ethnic group (29 CFR 1607.4(A)). For federal contractors, the Section 503 and VEVRAA rules name "interview notes" among records to keep for two years, or one year for contractors with fewer than 150 employees or a contract below $150,000 (Section 503) or $200,000 (VEVRAA) (41 CFR 60-741.80, 60-300.80). The Executive Order 11246 rules at 41 CFR Part 60-1, including the 60-1.12 retention rule, were removed effective October 26, 2026. Many employers store these notes in an applicant tracking system (ATS).
Questions employers ask. Must we ask every candidate the same questions? No federal statute says so, but OPM defines a structured interview that way and the Uniform Guidelines treat even informal interviews as selection procedures (29 CFR 1607.16). What if a candidate's story reveals a disability? The EEOC says an employer may ask limited accommodation questions when an applicant voluntarily discloses a hidden disability, and must keep medical information confidential. Does a small business have to validate its interview? The guidelines say use is in compliance if it is validated or does not result in adverse impact (29 CFR 1607.16(C)). How long do we keep interview notes? At least one year, longer for larger federal contractors or once a charge is filed (29 CFR 1602.14). For the wider hiring process, see talent acquisition.
Why it matters and common mistakes
Treating a conversational interview as outside the selection rules; the Uniform Guidelines include "informal or casual interviews" (29 CFR 1607.16).
Asking about sick days, past injuries or workers' compensation history before a conditional offer, which the EEOC guidance says is not allowed (29 CFR 1630.13).
Following up a behavioral answer with questions about a relative's health, which can be a request for family medical history under GINA (29 CFR 1635.8).
Asking only women about child care or family plans, which the EEOC calls clearly discriminatory.
Letting each interviewer pick questions and score by feel, the unstructured approach OPM links to low reliability and legal challenges.
Never checking interview pass rates by sex, race and ethnic group, so adverse impact below four-fifths goes unnoticed (29 CFR 1607.4).
Asking about pay history where state law bans it, such as California (Lab. Code 432.3) or Washington (RCW 49.58.100).
Discarding interview notes and rating forms before one year, or after a charge is filed (29 CFR 1602.14); larger federal contractors generally need two years (41 CFR 60-741.80, 60-300.80).
How Remindax helps
Remindax helps you track the dates and deadlines tied to interview record retention and hiring-stage follow-ups and sends reminders before they're due.
- ✓Reminders by Email, SMS and WhatsApp
- ✓An owner and a due date on every item
- ✓Forever-free plan, no credit card required
Sources & References
- *OPM - Structured Interviews: A Practical Guide (September 2008) - behavioral vs situational formats; past-behavior premise; sample questions; eight development steps; 4-6 competencies; 6-7 SMEs; rating scale levels; probes; administration; notes; panel consensus; rating errors
- *OPM - Assessment Decision Guide - degrees of structure and validity, rater agreement and adverse impact; critical incidents; behavioral description validity for complex work; validity table .51 and .38 (adapted from Schmidt and Hunter 1998)
- *29 CFR Part 1607 - Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures (eCFR) - scope; interviews as selection procedures; adverse impact; four-fifths rule; bottom line; impact records; content validity limits; ADEA and Rehabilitation Act not covered
- *42 U.S.C. 2000e-2 (GovInfo) - disparate impact burden of proof; job related and consistent with business necessity
- *29 CFR 1630.13 (eCFR) - pre-employment disability inquiries prohibited
- *29 CFR 1630.14 (eCFR) - inquiries into ability to perform job-related functions; describe or demonstrate
- *EEOC - Enforcement Guidance: Preemployment Disability-Related Questions and Medical Examinations (1995) - definition of disability-related question; attendance questions; sick days; workers' compensation history; reasonable accommodation questions
- *EEOC - Pre-Employment Inquiries and Disability - limited accommodation questions pre-offer; no questions on nature or severity
- *EEOC - Prohibited Employment Policies/Practices - pre-employment inquiries general rule; clubs and organizations; accommodation to apply; hiring tests
- *EEOC - Pre-Employment Inquiries and Marital Status or Number of Children - pregnancy, marital status, children, child care and spouse questions as evidence of intent
- *EEOC - Pre-Employment Inquiries and Religious Affiliation or Beliefs - avoid questions on place and days of worship; religious organization exemption
- *29 CFR 1635.8 (eCFR) - GINA prohibition on requesting genetic information; meaning of request; inadvertent acquisition; family medical history
- *EEOC - Genetic Information Discrimination - genetic information includes family medical history
- *29 CFR 1625.4 and 1625.5 (eCFR) - age inquiries not unlawful in themselves but closely scrutinized
- *EEOC - Coverage of Business/Private Employers - 15 employees (Title VII, ADA, GINA); 20 employees (ADEA)
- *29 CFR 1602.14 (eCFR) - one-year retention of hiring records; charge holds
- *29 CFR 1627.3 (eCFR) - ADEA one-year retention of applications and refusal-to-hire records
- *41 CFR 60-741.80 (eCFR) - Section 503 recordkeeping; interview notes; two years or one year below 150 employees or $150,000
- *41 CFR 60-300.80 (eCFR) - VEVRAA recordkeeping; interview notes; two years or one year below 150 employees or $200,000
- *Federal Register (govinfo) - Rescission of Executive Order 11246 Implementing Regulations (August 21, 2026) - 41 CFR Part 60-1 including 60-1.12 removed effective October 26, 2026; other agencies' application of UGESP not affected
- *California Labor Commissioner - California Equal Pay Act FAQ - example state salary history ban (Lab. Code 432.3); salary expectations; voluntary disclosure
- *Washington State Legislature - RCW 49.58.100 - example state ban on seeking wage or salary history; confirmation exceptions
Last reviewed: November 2026. Figures are reviewed annually - see Sources & References for current figures.
Keep every HR date on one calendar
Track the deadlines tied to interview record retention and hiring-stage follow-ups - with automatic reminders before anything is due.
GDPR-ready | AWS secure cloud | Encrypted storage | Setup under 5 minutes