Remindax does not provide legal, tax, or HR advisory services, and this page is for general informational purposes only - consult a qualified attorney, accountant, or HR professional for guidance specific to your situation.
Quick facts
- ✓No federal law defines or requires behavioral competencies for private employers; once they are used to hire, promote, rate or discipline, the EEO laws apply (EEOC). Title VII and the ADA cover employers with 15 or more employees; the ADEA, 20 or more.
- ✓OPM defines a competency as "a measurable pattern of knowledge, skills, abilities, behaviors, and other characteristics" and tells agencies to make competency definitions "behaviorally-based" with action verbs (OPM, checked November 2026).
- ✓Under the Uniform Guidelines, content validity is "not appropriate" for tests of traits or constructs "such as intelligence, aptitude, personality, commonsense, judgment, leadership" (29 CFR 1607.14(C)(1)).
- ✓The EEOC treats a psychological test as a medical examination if it provides evidence that would lead to identifying a mental disorder; under the ADA, medical examinations wait until after a conditional job offer (EEOC 1995 guidance; 29 CFR 1630.14).
- ✓O*NET OnLine lists 21 work styles in four groups and defines them as "personality tendencies exhibited at work" (DOL ETA, checked November 2026).
- ✓Hiring, promotion and test records must be kept at least one year (29 CFR 1602.14; 29 CFR 1627.3 for the ADEA).
- ✓Status, November 13, 2026: 29 CFR part 1607 is still in the eCFR, though OPM removed its references to it on July 31, 2026, after a June 9, 2026 Justice Department opinion.
What it means in practice
What the term covers. Many competency models have two parts. Technical competencies cover job content: knowing payroll tax rules, operating a forklift, writing code. Behavioral competencies cover how the work gets done: listening to customers, sharing information with a team, staying composed under pressure, owning mistakes. A behavioral competency is most useful when written as behavior someone else can observe. "Has a good attitude" is a judgment; "responds to coworker requests in a tactful manner" is a behavior.
How it differs from nearby terms. Core competencies are the capabilities an organization treats as central, or that it expects of every employee; some of them may be behavioral, but the term is about breadth, not type. Competency-based pay is a pay system that attaches pay steps to demonstrated competencies with its own Equal Pay Act and overtime issues. Work behavior is a defined legal term in the Uniform Guidelines: "an activity performed to achieve the objectives of the job" (29 CFR 1607.16(Y)). Behavioral competencies are an HR practice term; work behaviors are what a job analysis records to show a test is job related.
Key definitions. OPM calls a competency "a measurable pattern of knowledge, skills, abilities, behaviors, and other characteristics that an individual needs to perform work roles or occupational functions successfully," and says competencies specify the "how" of performing job tasks. The Uniform Guidelines define "observable" as "able to be seen, heard, or otherwise perceived by a person other than the person performing the action" and an ability as "a present competence to perform an observable behavior or a behavior which results in an observable product." They add that knowledges, skills and abilities "are not behaviors, although they may be applied in work behaviors" (29 CFR 1607.16(A), (O), (Y)). O*NET separates work styles, "personality tendencies exhibited at work," such as Dependability, Integrity, Self-Control, Cooperation and Adaptability, from work activities, "general types of job behaviors occurring on multiple jobs." O*NET is a descriptive resource, not a legal standard.
The federal-agency model. These rules bind federal agencies, not private employers, but offer a detailed public model. OPM says its MOSAIC occupational studies have identified the critical competencies and tasks for nearly 200 federal occupations and leadership positions, so agencies can use one set of competencies for job design, recruitment, selection, performance management, training and career development. OPM's proficiency-level guide rates leadership competencies on five levels, from Level 1 (Awareness), applying the competency "in the simplest situations," to Level 5 (Expert). For Interpersonal Skills, defined as treating "others with courtesy, sensitivity, and respect," a Level 1 illustration is "Interacts with co-workers in a tactful manner" and a Level 3 illustration is "Corrects employee mistakes in a courteous manner." OPM's current Executive Core Qualifications, revised since that guide, list five ECQs; "Leading People" includes Accountability and Developing Others. Federal rules also require every federal employment practice to rest on a job analysis identifying duties, the knowledges, skills and abilities required, and the factors important in evaluating candidates, with "a rational relationship" to job performance (5 CFR 300.103). For federal appraisals, a performance standard "may include, but is not limited to, quality, quantity, timeliness, and manner of performance" (5 CFR 430.203); manner of performance is where behavior is rated.
How it works for an employer, step by step. (1) Start from the job: identify the important work behaviors and how they are performed, then link each behavioral competency to them; see job description. (2) Write each definition as behavior. OPM's writing guide says to define a competency simply, keep it to "a single, readily identifiable characteristic," make it "behaviorally-based" with action verbs such as "Recognizes" or "Organizes," drop qualifiers like "Thorough Knowledge," and have subject matter experts review it. (3) Choose an assessment method. OPM describes structured interviews as measuring competencies "by systematically inquiring about their behavior in past experiences and/or their proposed behavior in hypothetical situations," with the same questions and rating scale for every candidate; see behavioral-based interview questions. Situational judgment tests measure "social functioning dimensions such as conflict management, interpersonal skills, problem solving." (4) Rate against defined anchors, such as proficiency illustrations, in hiring and in the performance review. (5) Check outcomes by sex, race and ethnic group, and (6) keep the records.
The validity problem with traits. The Uniform Guidelines apply to any selection procedure used for an employment decision, from tests to "informal or casual interviews and unscored application forms," and decisions include hiring, promotion, demotion and retention (29 CFR 1607.2(B), 1607.16(Q)). They do not require validity studies where no adverse impact results (1607.1(B)). Where impact exists, the strategy matters. A procedure "based upon inferences about mental processes cannot be supported solely or primarily on the basis of content validity," so a test labeled "judgment" or "leadership" needs criterion-related or construct evidence (1607.14(C)(1)). A skill or ability should be "operationally defined in terms of observable aspects of work behavior of the job," and the closer a procedure is to a work sample, "the stronger is the basis for showing content validity" (1607.14(C)(4)). Supervisor ratings used as validation criteria carry a warning: "supervisory rating techniques and instructions to raters should be carefully developed" because of possible bias in subjective evaluations (1607.14(B)(2)).
What the testing methods look like. OPM says personality tests "tend to be less valid" than cognitive ability tests, assessment centers and work samples, and their items can be easy to fake; SJTs show moderately high criterion-related validity and "typically moderate" subgroup differences. The EEOC says a vendor's validity documentation "may be helpful," but the employer "is still responsible" for its tests.
Title VII and the ADEA. Title VII allows an employer to act on "any professionally developed ability test" that is not "designed, intended or used to discriminate" (42 U.S.C. 2000e-2(h)). A neutral practice with a disparate impact is unlawful if the employer cannot show it is "job related for the position in question and consistent with business necessity," or refuses a less discriminatory alternative (2000e-2(k)). The EEOC says employers may not adjust scores or use different cutoffs by race, color, religion, sex or national origin, and may not base hiring decisions on stereotypes. The four-fifths rule of thumb is explained on the adverse impact page. The Guidelines do not apply to the ADEA (1607.2(D)); for age, the EEOC says a test with an age-based disparate impact must rest on a reasonable factor other than age.
The ADA: behavior standards and personality tests. The EEOC lists "demonstrating certain attributes such as the ability to work with other people or to work under pressure" as a qualification standard. If an applicant or employee cannot meet one because of a disability, the employer must show it is "job-related and consistent with business necessity," tied to an essential function, meaning "the fundamental job duties" of the position, not marginal ones (29 CFR 1630.2(n)). Employees with disabilities must meet the same qualitative standards as others, and lowering a standard is not a reasonable accommodation, though help meeting it may be. On tests, the EEOC says psychological examinations "are medical if they provide evidence that would lead to identifying a mental disorder," while a test "designed and used to measure only things such as honesty, tastes, and habits" is not medical. OPM names the MMPI as an example of a medical test. Before an offer, medical examinations are barred; after a conditional offer, they are allowed if given to all entering employees in the job category (29 CFR 1630.14(b)). The ADA also requires accommodation in test administration. See Americans with Disabilities Act.
Labor law. The NLRB says an employer may not threaten employees with adverse consequences for protected concerted activity, such as a group complaint to management about working conditions, though an employee can lose protection through misconduct. This applies in non-union workplaces too, which matters when rating competencies like "teamwork."
Example 1: rewriting a vague competency. Our illustration of OPM's writing tips. "Positive attitude: shows a great attitude at all times" becomes "Customer focus: greets each customer, confirms the request, and explains next steps or a referral before ending the contact." The second version names one characteristic, uses action verbs, drops the qualifier "at all times," and can be rated by an observer.
Example 2: checking a promotion assessment. Our illustration of 29 CFR 1607.4(D). Forty men and 25 women take a situational judgment test for promotion to shift lead. Thirty men pass (75 percent) and 12 women pass (48 percent). Dividing 48 by 75 gives 64 percent, below four-fifths, which the enforcement agencies would generally regard as evidence of adverse impact and which would put the test's validity evidence at issue.
Example 3: keeping interview rating sheets. Our illustration of 29 CFR 1602.14. Competency rating sheets from a promotion decided on February 10, 2026 are kept until at least February 10, 2027. If a Title VII, ADA or GINA charge is filed, all relevant records, including other candidates' test papers, are kept until final disposition. Users with 100 or fewer employees may meet the Guidelines' recordkeeping with simplified yearly counts (1607.15(A)(1)).
Where states differ: integrity tests. Integrity is a common behavioral competency, and states can regulate how it is tested. The federal Employee Polygraph Protection Act rules exclude written or oral "honesty" or "paper and pencil" tests from the definition of lie detector (29 CFR 801.2(d)(2)). As one example of a state that goes further, Massachusetts defines a lie detector test to include a "written examination" used or interpreted by an examiner to render "a diagnostic opinion regarding the honesty of an individual," bars employers from requiring one, requires a notice on all applications, and sets a fine of $300 to $1,000 for a first violation (M.G.L. c. 149, section 19B). Check your own state's labor department or statutes.
Federal enforcement posture in 2026. On June 9, 2026, the Justice Department announced an Office of Legal Counsel opinion telling the EEOC its disparate-impact guidelines are unconstitutional. OPM's July 31, 2026 interim final rule removed Uniform Guidelines references from federal personnel rules but kept the job-analysis, rational-relationship and "professionally developed" requirements. The Title VII disparate impact provision, 42 U.S.C. 2000e-2(k), remains in the U.S. Code, and private plaintiffs can still sue under it.
Questions employers ask. Are behavioral competencies legal to use in hiring? Yes; no federal law bars them, but the assessments are selection procedures subject to Title VII, the ADA and the ADEA (29 CFR 1607.16(Q)). Can we use a personality test? Before an offer, only if it is not medical under the EEOC's test; OPM advises tests designed for normal adult populations. Do interviews count? Yes; the Guidelines' definition includes informal interviews (1607.16(Q)). Must we validate every competency? The Guidelines call for validity evidence where a procedure has adverse impact (1607.1(B), 1607.3). See also performance management.
Why it matters and common mistakes
Defending a "leadership," "judgment" or personality measure on content validity alone, which 29 CFR 1607.14(C)(1) rules out for traits and constructs.
Rating competencies such as "attitude" or "culture fit" without written behavioral definitions; the Guidelines warn of bias in subjective supervisory ratings (1607.14(B)(2)).
Giving a clinical personality inventory, such as the MMPI, before a conditional job offer; the EEOC and OPM treat such tests as ADA medical examinations.
Assuming a vendor's validation report settles the question; the EEOC says the employer remains responsible for its tests.
Adjusting scores or setting different cutoffs by race, color, religion, sex or national origin, which Title VII bars (42 U.S.C. 2000e-2(l), as described by the EEOC).
Refusing to accommodate an employee with a disability in taking a behavioral assessment, or lowering the standard instead of helping the employee meet it (EEOC).
Rating an employee down on "teamwork" for joining coworkers in a complaint about working conditions (NLRB, protected concerted activity).
Discarding interview rating sheets and test papers before one year, or after a charge is filed (29 CFR 1602.14, 1627.3).
Using a written honesty test in Massachusetts on the assumption that the federal polygraph rules settle the question (29 CFR 801.2(d)(2); M.G.L. c. 149, section 19B).
How Remindax helps
Remindax helps you track the dates and deadlines tied to competency assessments, performance review cycles and EEO record retention and sends reminders before they're due.
- ✓Reminders by Email, SMS and WhatsApp
- ✓An owner and a due date on every item
- ✓Forever-free plan, no credit card required
Sources & References
- *OPM - Competencies (Assessment and Selection) - definition of competency; uses; MOSAIC studies covering nearly 200 federal occupations; OPM notice that it is rescinding or revising guidance on the page
- *OPM - Writing Competencies (PDF) - single characteristic; behaviorally-based definitions with action verbs; removing qualifiers; SME review
- *OPM - Proficiency Levels for Leadership Competencies (PDF) - five proficiency levels; Interpersonal Skills definition and Level 1 and Level 3 illustrations
- *OPM - Executive Core Qualifications - five current ECQs; Leading People competencies including Executive Judgement
- *OPM - Structured Interviews - definition of structured interview; same questions and rating scale
- *OPM - Personality Tests - what personality tests measure; Big Five; relative validity; faking; MMPI as ADA medical examination; normal adult populations
- *OPM - Situational Judgment Tests - social functioning dimensions measured; content and criterion-related validity; moderate subgroup differences
- *eCFR - 5 CFR part 300, subpart A (Employment Practices) - section 300.103: job analysis, rational relationship, professionally developed (as amended 91 FR 48236)
- *eCFR - 5 CFR 430.203 (Performance management definitions) - performance standard includes quality, quantity, timeliness and manner of performance; critical element
- *eCFR - 29 CFR part 1607, Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures - sections 1607.1(B), 1607.2, 1607.3, 1607.4(D), 1607.14(B)(2), 1607.14(C)(1) and (C)(4), 1607.15(A)(1), 1607.16(A), (O), (Q), (Y); text as of 2026-11-01
- *O*NET OnLine - Browse by Work Styles - work styles definition; 21 styles in four groups
- *O*NET OnLine - Browse by Work Activities - work activities as general types of job behaviors
- *EEOC - Coverage of Business/Private Employers - 15-employee and 20-employee coverage thresholds
- *EEOC - Prohibited Employment Policies/Practices - no hiring or promotion decisions based on stereotypes; tests must be job related
- *EEOC - Employment Tests and Selection Procedures - personality and integrity tests as selection procedures; score adjustment ban; ADA testing rules; ADEA reasonable factor other than age; employer responsible despite vendor documentation
- *EEOC - Enforcement Guidance: Preemployment Disability-Related Questions and Medical Examinations (October 10, 1995) - when psychological tests are medical; honesty, tastes and habits tests not medical
- *EEOC - Applying Performance and Conduct Standards to Employees with Disabilities - attributes such as working with others as qualification standards; same qualitative standards; lowering standards not an accommodation
- *eCFR - 29 CFR 1630.2 (ADA definitions) - paragraph (n): essential functions
- *eCFR - 29 CFR 1630.14 (Medical examinations and inquiries specifically permitted) - post-offer examinations for all entering employees in the job category
- *GovInfo - 42 U.S.C. 2000e-2 (Title VII, section 703) - subsection (h) professionally developed ability tests; subsection (k) disparate impact burden of proof
- *NLRB - Interfering with employee rights (Section 7 and 8(a)(1)) - no threats for protected concerted activity; definition of concerted and protected; loss of protection through misconduct
- *eCFR - 29 CFR 1602.14 (Preservation of records made or kept) - one-year retention; records kept until final disposition after a charge; other candidates' test papers
- *eCFR - 29 CFR 1627.3 (ADEA records to be kept by employers) - one-year retention of promotion, training selection and test records
- *eCFR - 29 CFR 801.2 (Employee Polygraph Protection Act definitions) - written or oral honesty tests excluded from the federal lie detector definition
- *Massachusetts General Laws c. 149, section 19B (Lie detector tests) - state example: definition includes written examinations; application notice; fines
- *U.S. Department of Justice - Justice Department Concludes EEOC Disparate-Impact Guidelines Violate the Constitution (June 9, 2026) - date and summary of the OLC opinion
- *Federal Register (govinfo) - OPM, Removal of References to UGESP in Federal Personnel Regulations (91 FR 48234, July 31, 2026) - interim final rule effective July 31, 2026; job analysis, rational relationship and professionally developed requirements kept
Last reviewed: November 2026. Figures are reviewed annually - see Sources & References for current figures.
Keep every HR date on one calendar
Track the deadlines tied to competency assessments, performance review cycles and EEO record retention - with automatic reminders before anything is due.
GDPR-ready | AWS secure cloud | Encrypted storage | Setup under 5 minutes